Advertisement

Opinion: Sensible immigration policy: saved by the veto

Share

This article was originally on a blog post platform and may be missing photos, graphics or links. See About archive blog posts.

Arizona Gov. Janet Napolitano is a politician after LAPD Chief William Bratton’s heart. The governor vetoed a bill Monday that would have required police departments to, as the NY Times put it, ‘join the federal immigration posse.’ The governor’s merciless pen has received mixed reviews, but it’s no surprise. The two-term governor holds her state’s record for most vetoes issued.

As noted here a few weeks ago, the bill had an interesting parallel to Los Angeles’ current drama over Special Order 40, the LAPD directive that bars officers from stopping people ‘for the sole purpose of asking about immigration status.’ The order came under fire when high school football star Jamiel Shaw was gunned down, allegedly by an illegal immigrant, but Bratton has defended the policy to the hilt — and rightly so, according to The Times:

Advertisement

The order was adopted in the late 1970s by then-Chief Daryl F. Gates, hardly a soft-on-crime liberal, who knew that the LAPD would be more effective if undocumented witnesses and victims felt free to speak with officers without fearing deportation.... It was good policy then and remains so today.

The governor didn’t actually pull the ‘crimefighting’ card herself when she vetoed it:

Napolitano, a Democrat, had been urged to reject House Bill 2807 by Latino activists who feared the measure would lead to racial profiling and further alienate the Latino community. But Napolitano cited neither of those issues in vetoing the measure. Instead, she relied on fiscal concerns, noting a provision that would have required the state to pay for the training of local officers in immigration enforcement if federal funds were unavailable.

In fact, Napolitano has been very clear that this ain’t no sanctuary state. In an Op-Ed for the Washington Post urging Congress to pass comprehensive immigration reform last year, she wrote:

Don’t label me soft on illegal immigration. As a U.S. attorney (predating the Gonzales Justice Department), I supervised the prosecution of more than 6,000 immigration felonies. I govern a state where, in 2005, there were 550,000 apprehensions of illegal immigrants. I declared a state of emergency at our border that year, and I was the first governor in the nation to call for assistance from the National Guard.

Okay then. In any case, go Janet!

Advertisement