Opinion L.A.

The best in Southern California opinion journalism,
Monday through Friday

« Previous Post | Opinion L.A. Home | Next Post »

Poll: Was Gov. Schwarzenegger right to order another furlough day?

July 1, 2009 |  1:44 pm

California budget, furloughs, Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger, public employee unions, SEIU Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger and Republicans in the Legislature are playing hardball with their Democratic counterparts: No new taxes, balance the budget with cuts and -- as Schwarzenegger ordered earlier today -- force state employees to take a third monthly furlough day, further reducing their pay. According to The Times' article, thousands of public employees plan to show up in Sacramento today to protest the additional pay cut.

The third imposed furlough day opens a deeper divide in one of the more drawn-out battles of this year's budgeting process: the one pitting public-employee unions and their Democratic allies in the Legislature against Schwarzenegger and state Republicans, who seemed to have rekindled their relationship after the May 19 special election. It's a topic being debated in this week's Dust-Up exchange between Jon Coupal of the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn. and John Tanner, executive director of SEIU Local 721, which represents tens of thousands of government employees in Los Angeles County (their third and final exchange, in which they mull ideas to preserve state services in this budget crisis without reducing pay or laying off workers, will be posted later today). In the comments board for Monday's Dust-Up installment, several readers have come down on the side of Schwarzenegger and the GOP, posting comments similar the one left by "Pete":

The unions are a major part of the problem. Even as a liberal Democrat and a former union member, I can no longer support the entrenched self-interest of the AFL-CIO and in particular the SEIU in California. The millstone around the State's neck has many contributors to the weight besides Labor. But the current union contracts and negotiating positions are a huge impediment for California's [economic] re-development in today's world, and I hope Gov. [Schwarzenegger] digs his heels in even if he must suffer short-term political suicide. He will be seen as a hero in the long run.

What do you think of Schwarzenegger's action on state employees? Leave a comment below, take our poll or throw caution to the wind and do both.


Photo: Service Employees International Union protest Schwarzenegger's proposed furloughs and state employee pay cuts Tuesday, June 30 (Rich Pedroncelli/AP) 


Post a comment
If you are under 13 years of age you may read this message board, but you may not participate.
Here are the full legal terms you agree to by using this comment form.

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until they've been approved.

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In





Comments
1.

i work for the state and resent all the vicious rantings in the sacbee, fresno bee etc. i work at a developmental center in the san joaquin valley. we serve court ordered developmentallly disabled adults who have committed crimes but have been judged incompetent to stand trial. i worked hard to become licenced as a psych tech. i work hard at my job. since we are 24/7 care, i work hard 3 days a month for free. the people i work with would scare the crap out of some folks. they can be assaultive, delusional, inappropriate to an extreme. these folks need the services which department of developmental services and department of mental health provide. or we can just stick them in jail where they will complete their sentence and be released to reoffend over and over because of not receiving treatment and appropriate placement aftercare. this protects citizens from crimes being perpetrated upon them. many of these folks commited crimes like rape and child molestation. we all agree that measures must be taken, but it appears to us that the state employee has been forced to bear the brunt of economic pain as well as being portrayed to the tax paying public as public enemy # 1. don't forget that we also pay taxes, consume goods, and by and large are registered voters. the saving being realized by punishing ca state employees is a drop in the bucket to what is required to balance the budget. sacramento has not forced the people in the capital building to forgo 3 days pay, nor have certain state entities furloughed their employees. what vital service do these people provide to the citizens of the state of ca? can you say expense account, per diem, honorary 128K position for being ahnold's friend, don't forget nice leased vehicles which are paid for by me and you! how come no one is ranting and raving about accomodations and tax breaks given to big oil and special interest lobbies. thats where the red ink is bleeding from.

2.

California and the rest of the states need to add 12-20 million illegals to the mix. LOL We reap what we sow!
Obama is not enforcing immigration laws just like those before him. LOL Where is the rage of the 14 million unemployed Americans. When Caifornia pays 1 illegal woman with 5 kids (4 born here) the following!
$650 a month for each of the 4 American Born kids
$500 a month in food stamps for Mom
$3100 a month total for mom who is an illegal! LOL
And you wonder why we are broke!

3.

This isn't about right wing or left wing. We have a moderate Republican Governor and a Democratic representation across the board. Both parties (and the people who vote for them, thats us) have continued to raise budgets in good times, and then raise them even more in bad times. Common sense tells me that you pull back your budgets in bad times. If a person is in foreclosure on his house, and in bankruptcy, the equivalent of California (and the U.S. Federal Gov't.) would be for this person to go out and get an extra credit card to max that card out to, just before he loses everything he has. You know, like what will happen to us soon.

4.

Mr Schwarzenegger Still hasn't gotten it, Some of these services are 24/7. What's going to happen is that the under staffed police, firefighters, nurses, and other crucial public services for have an increase in Mandatory Overtime. This time and a half pay will skyrocket the budget even more. Closing State Parks will destroy the surrounding local commerce and he continues to put these parks on the chopping block. Next lets cut state assistance to the poor, disables, mentally ill, and elderly. This is going to cause a backlash on a local level and californians will still have to shell out. It's just redistribution of the expenses in an attempt to make himself look like a hero. The problem is, not only is he looking like an idiot, he's running us further in dept. Either way the middle class is going to pay, so let's just man up and be honest about it Arnie!

5.

I am a state employee, working in an agency that is self-supporting and does not exist on any money from the general fund. Yet, with this additional furlough day, my pay will have been cut 14% this year.
My mother is dying of cancer in Utah. This pay cut will force me to make a Hobson's choice - either I visit her while she is alive, or attend her funeral. I will not be able to afford both. I would sure like to have Arnold's millions right now.

6.

Here are the reasons why california is broke.

-Ever growing unions in public sector.

-Ever growing salaries and benefits. State employees can retire at 50 and get upto 90% of their last years salary in pensions. Fire fighter and police officers can easily make over 100,000/year in pension. Now the state is paying these retirees and current employees over 100k salaries.

-Ever growing medical bills. These state employees get paid insurance as part of the retirement. We pay 25 to 35 as copay but these unions go on strike if they are asked to pay $10.00

-During growth year unions add more employees but during slow down they don't cut the numbers, the best they can do is furloughs.

Democratic leadership is in bed with the union bosses. Thank god we have the 2/3 majority, otherwise unions would have drained more public funds and democrats would have happily increased the taxes.

Posted by: bill | July 01, 2009 at 08:03 PM

=======================
Sorry Bill but Swartzneggar has been the governor for a while now and has fought the unions and deminished them for a long time. Remember the Nurses Union he called special interest and he kicks their butt?

No this is Bush like failed economic policies that Republicans practice and ruin economy then blame unions, illegals or whomever is the target group flavor of the month.

Let Corporations earn (GROSS) Gross profits on the backs of the middle class then blame unions. Think Unions caused the gas price increases lately with nothing driving the prices up? Think again.

7.

Why not just recall Swartzneggar and get Governor who will do his job and not pressure Congress to abandon the people THEY represent.

It is dead wrong to steal from education and children's or anyone's health without taxing tobacco, liquor and oil.

8.

Al Salas Posted “Let's privatize the jails, DMV and other services.”

Right and what good would that do?

Go ahead and privative jails and see the negative impact it will have. I think you need to do a little research on private jails and the high escape numbers that they represent.

And please do not look in some little poe dink county with low level criminals, look for level 4 max security yards and see how ineffective they have been.

Let some psycho manic or raving lunatic get out and molest the neighborhood or worse and ask yourself if it was worth the cost savings to “get rid of the fat pensions.”

9.

Bill posted "State employees can retire at 50 and get up to 90% of their last year’s salary in pensions. Fire fighter and police officers can easily make over 100,000/year in pension.

Well this is true, but it takes them 30 years of working the toughest jobs to get that 90% pension. And the door is always open to those willing to place their lives on the line to make society a safer place, so I would say if it is all that wonderful and glorious, why not apply for a position?

I would ask Bill, when was the last time he had a building collapse on him while fighting a fire to save someone’s life? Or when was the last time he got a vial substance made from an inmate’s body fluids thrown in his face while he was trying to make a count to ensure all inmates were in there cells. Or when was the last time he got shot at by some wacko, while responding to a back up call of someone trying to beat down his wife?

I would venture to say: Never, but he enjoys the benefits provided by those that have and do every day.

10.

WOW - This totally blows my mind. I can now see why the Legislature cannot pass a budget, the people in this BLOG cannot even agree on issues.
Everyone keeps blasting the Unions, State workers, Republicans, Democrats and no one seems to agree on anything.
Look people, there is not one side or the other that is all right or all wrong here, it was and is a collection of joint decisions made by the 37 million people in the state of California that made this state that way it is.
I agree that some unions have gotten too strong and have lost vision of what they are here for, to insure "EQUAL" pay for "Equal" work, the elimination of sweat shops, and protection from wrongful firing.
I agree there are some State workers and State jobs that should be reduced and in some cases eliminated, but not all. Remember for evey increase in taxes not only does the state worker now have to absorb and deal with them but they need to do it with 15% less in pay. They are taking a double hit, unlike the private sector who just takes the hit for the tax increase.
And yes the Democrats want to raise taxes and the republicans want to make cuts, but not all cuts are bad and not all taxes increase are either, if you want to move forward you need a balance.
But at a time of crises it is not good to keep voting for stuff a state cannot afford, like road improvements, free lunch programs at school, free heath care for illegal’s and free hand outs to people who do not want to work, but instead want to lay around the house have kids and live off welfare.
All those monies should be stripped away and moved into Education, Heath care for elderly and the disabled, but again only in so much as we can afford it.
At this point and time California cannot afford to give away free rides, and if we have to tighten our belts then we need to do it as a State not as individuals, it is time to stop pointing fingers and start working together to get this state on track.

11.

Let's privatize the jails, DMV and other services. This would get rid of the fat pensions. If you tax oil , oil is going to tax you. Who cares what Exon made. The Politicians and their union thugs have no right to anyone's money including Exon.

12.

I see a lot of blame on these posts. Blame isn't going to solve these problems. We all need to compromise. State workers have already made sacrifices with the 2 furlough days initiated earlier in the year. The issue is becoming a dead horse. We can continue beating it, or we can move on and use our innovation to come up with a range of solutions. We can tax cigarettes and alcohol, tax oil drilling, close tax loop holes. The Legislature should also agree to take the pay cuts they are asking others to take. It seems the conservative Republican side is unbending. We ALL must bend. A compromise means we must work together and sometimes agree to things we do not like, such as furloughs. If furloughs are a solution, tax increases should be as well. Especially on the big corporations. If we are not careful, they will be the only ones left standing.

13.

Green shoots? We'll get green shoots!

Right after the current financial fire burns our forest of political deadwood to the ground. All that self-absorbed, liberal, baby boomer dry rot has to go. When it does, a new generation will grow up in the aftermath, tough, savvy and hard like the folks who lived through the 1930's.

They will be the green shoots that rebuild America with classic values of thrift, industry and responsibility. We can only hope they don't spoil their kids as badly as the Boomers' parents did, and so avoid creating another generational train wreck like that.

14.

Liberal Baby Boomers, I hang this mess around your collective necks. Your parents lived through the last Depression, the Second World War, shortages, rationing and sacrifice. They set a good example financially and most of you went a different direction. That direction was up over your heads in debt, wrapped in wishful thinking that debt was money, on a foundation of denial & narcissistic self-delusion. "I'm special, I deserve it, the good times will never end, housing never goes down, everyone wants to live here, anyone against open borders is a bad person, live for the moment, don't be hung up, etc."

Well, you all are in charge now and look where we are: most citizens, states and, indeed, the US gov't can feel insolvency closing in behind them. You wild-spenders deserve the old age of destitution that's coming to you, but the trouble is there are so many of you that you may well take the system down too. If so, then the Baby Boomers will go down in history as the generation that wrecked America.

Your parents gave you the greatest nation in world history, & you will give your children a bankrupt shell of a nation, likely indebted to foreign masters. Most people would be ashamed of that, though I doubt most of you can look past next week long enough to see it, let alone care.

15.

The electorate wants government spending paid for with the state's visa card until the card is maxed out. With the highest taxes in the nation, we should all be ashamed that we allowed our state government to get this out of control. Other states like New York and our federal government will soon follow our lead to insolvency.

The 21st century will not be an American century as the 20th Century was, precisely because of our collective fiscal irresponsibility as citizens. The party is over, now enjoy the hangover and bills.

16.

I thought Arnold came up with a pretty freaking good Idea, which was of course squashed by the CA legislature: if the state hired x-number of people to AUDIT SOCIAL SERVICES RECIPIENTS AND STOP THE FRUAD, we would save billions every year. I live in a quiet suburb of L.A., and the number of people I have come across who proudly admit they're "on the Obama Plan (fraudulent welfare)" is staggering. It has to STOP.

17.

Here are the reasons why california is broke.

-Ever growing unions in public sector.

-Ever growing salaries and benefits. State employees can retire at 50 and get upto 90% of their last years salary in pensions. Fire fighter and police officers can easily make over 100,000/year in pension. Now the state is paying these retirees and current employees over 100k salaries.

-Ever growing medical bills. These state employees get paid insurance as part of the retirement. We pay 25 to 35 as copay but these unions go on strike if they are asked to pay $10.00

-During growth year unions add more employees but during slow down they don't cut the numbers, the best they can do is furloughs.

Democratic leadership is in bed with the union bosses. Thank god we have the 2/3 majority, otherwise unions would have drained more public funds and democrats would have happily increased the taxes.

18.

You deserve this. Either bust the unions, ship the illegals back to the Purgatory they came from, and adopt fiscal sanity RIGHT NOW, or you may end up with actual social instability.

I'm mad as hell and I'm not going to take it anymore!

19.

Some state employees are obviously over paid, like in any other indipendent company, or other gov offices.
But mostly it looks like they are robbing the poor to give to the poorer..Robinhood effect...but hey guys, a lot of independent companies have taken pay decreases with no days off, a furlough with a day off is better than a pay cut.

Get on with it legislature and get this budget passed with no tax increases.

People should have had better since than to have a family any size before getting a job that will support them and have ability to have medical insurance..common since.. and stop living a fairy tail mother God mother will take care of me approach. There was no welfare when I grew up, the poor grew up knowing they had to work, when did that become a disgrace.

20.

LET IT CRASH !!! We can't fix it until it is thoroughly BUSTED. Let hope the State is forced to declare BANKRUPTSY. VOID all union contracts, pensions, retirements and perks. At that point we can begin to rebuild our State, and eliminate those programs which attract welfare recipients. Also eliminate unnecessary bureaucratic positions from State Government.

21.

1. Some of you wackos in here are totally uneducated and uninformed. No.. it is not true that state employees are already sharing the pain that private industries are. Proove it, give me a credible link. In fact it is a fact that they have hired 1000 more employees since arnold threatned to layoff 5000 employees when none has. Why is it that private sectors go bankrupt and shed jobs when all you govt employees are protected? I have a friend who works for govt and self confessed making 60k/year to stare at a wall 4 days a week with one of those other days breaking rocks. Talk about waste from govn't?

2. DId you know that the state budget has increased tremendously in the past 5 years? All those years when they were getting record surplus they did not save for rainny day funds instead they put it and spent it in more programs. The state's budget has quadruple in the past 10 years when our population hasn't grown all that much. Go out there and do some research you wack job idiots who claimed that we can't cut these jobs. We have plenty of cuts to do. Why bloat the budget up when the services required aren't needed.

3. There are less tax payers and more tax takers in this state. Another source of the problem. Education? Illegal immigrants are a problem to this state, it is the reason why we have more students in classrooms than we're supposed to get. They drain approx 15 billion/year. That's a huge number. The middle class are already paying their butts off and they planned more taxes? What? To drive more tax payers out and take more tax takers like illegal immigrants? Such as Obama's health care plan is like a magnet to attracts these flees and scumbags to suck the tax payers dry.

22.

Yeah right Pau-anything to save a buck! Well don't worry-it won't be long before YOU'LL be getting paid with IOU's-then you won't have to worry at all about taxes my friend!Then when you need public services you'll have to speak to someone overseas who speaks poor english you won't understand, and not be able to get help-then what? Ehhh??? Some patriot you are-giving even more American jobs away so some international CEO's and stockholders can reap the rewards-NO THANKS!!!!

23.

There really seems to be a lot of misinformation out there. For one thing, all public employee salaries are public information. Anyone can request the salary schedule and benefits provided to public workers. I wish we could say the same about private corporations and the savings they recieve in corporate tax loopholes. Everyone deserves to make a decent wage and have the ability to provide for themselves. No one has to pay more taxes...but in that choice comes the consequenses of having less services. That is true of anything. Don't expect to pay 2 star hotel prices and get 5 star quality and service. Our state has become a 2 star hotel and no one wants to step up and pay for the quality that they have grown to expect. Our schools are a prime example. We are 47 in the nation in per pupil spending and our average test scores reflect that. You get what you pay for.

24.

Where is the money that Arnold takes from our fellow working class member, union and non-union, going?

In 2008 Exxon posted a record $45 billion in profits. Chevron posted $23.9 billion. An increase in the cost of gasoline sends the price of all market items higher. Think of something that doesn't depend on gasoline. How much of the state budget went to those profits. And here we are blaming working class folks for the states problems. Some of you don't want to see the tips of your noses.

The bottom 20% of Americans earn less than $20,000 annually. And these are the folks we know about. The ones that haven't been swept under the rug.

Those who care are only asking that we all share. Arnold and folks in his financial class can afford to give up three days of pay a month without breaking a sweat, but how many folks in his class are giving up a penny or two of their millions/billions? Do you know any who have shared?

It's time to take another look. But then why change things just because the majority of Californians or the majority of the U.S. or the world's population barely make ends meet. Who cares? Let em sleep in a doorway.

25.

Michael....
Amazing what the staggering incompetency of Swarzeneggar and his fellow Republicans have done to this state. Add to this the idiots in the state who elected him and want services without having to pay for them.


Atleast he is trying to stop the UNION and democrat stop raising TAX! Forget the bonus and perks, we can layoff or outsourcse 50% our job over sea save tax payer money in the long run. Democrat and Union ......u make Arnold is look like robin hood to the tax payer

 


Advertisement

About the Bloggers
Opinion L.A. is the work of the Los Angeles Times editorial board.



Recent Posts
Dream (or nightmare) team |  November 24, 2009, 11:16 am »
Making a list and checking it seven times |  November 24, 2009, 11:13 am »
Thank thee, bishops |  November 20, 2009, 1:23 pm »

Archives