Opinion L.A.

Observations and provocations
from The Times' Opinion staff

« Previous Post | Opinion L.A. Home | Next Post »

The Mormon missionaries and the lesbians

adcampaignelection daygaylesbianproposition 8same-sex marriagevote

The Yes on 8 campaign is doing its best to spread its outrage -- outrage!! -- over the latest ad against Proposition 8, which would amend the state constitution to take away the right of gay and lesbian couples to wed.

The ad, which debuted on YouTube and is going out on television today, is certainly the most attention-getting TV spot to criticize the proposition. Most of the ads against Proposition 8 have been extraordinarily tame, unlike the fear-mongering rumors spread by the Yes side.

Not any more. The new ad -- a skit in which two actors playing Mormon missionaries visit the home of a married lesbian couple -- is clearly intended to signal viewers that the Mormon church has been a major player in the Yes campaign. Its message is that the religious right is claiming the power to strip others of their rights, starting with marriage and heading into any other arenas the movement finds immoral.

Having viewed the ad, I can't see what the big deal is. Skits like this are common fodder for campaign ads. Were opponents of Prop. 8 supposed to never touch the religious aspect of this? Is it supposed to be unfair to play the Mormon card, considering the role Mormonism has played on the Yes side (e.g., pressing its members to donate and work for the campaign)? Surely the Mormon church and its members never expected to leap into a campaign with this much vocal and financial might, funding it in large part and pushing for it relentlessly, without expecting that they would be viewed as a force that is trying to roll back the clock on gay rights in California. And considering that the Yes on 8 campaign has tried to depict gays and lesbians as attempting to take over elementary schools and force themselves on religious weddings, it's not in a great position to claim bigotry and intolerance, let alone misleading advertising, coming from the other side.

The "missionaries" show up at the front door .... but watch and judge for yourself.

 

Comments () | Archives (91)

The comments to this entry are closed.

John S.

Wow, the hatred and name calling coming from the Gay community is unbelievable. What happened to the concept of tolerance and love. It looks like tolerance and love only applies one way.

Gays and Gay supporters only want others to tolerate, accept and love them but they seem to have utter disrespect for anyone that doesn't see things exactly as they do. My goodness how far society has come.

Prop 8 is about defining the term Marriage as between a Man and a Woman. If Prop 8 passes, Gays can still form Unions which have ALL the same rights as mandated by state Law.

If you don't like the term Civil Union, then please put your creative energy into coming up with a better term that defines your relationship.

sakuranoko

I found this great timeline on same-sex marriage issues that covers 1970 to the present. It offers great insight in to the ongoing battle without presenting a biased opinion, just straight facts.

http://borngay.procon.org/viewresource.asp?resourceID=25

jeffrey Root

I'm a No on 8 supporter and this commercial makes us look like a bunch of fools. Why the hell did they release this video? We are supposed to be teaching Tolerance not hate. Vote No on 8 but not because of this hypocritical commercial.

BCA

I'm a Mormon and I say "sweet payback" for the blackmail letter sent to the no on prop 8 business contributors. This is hardball politics. What did you expect?

Big Wave Dave

I had been undecided, and leaning toward voting no on 8 when I go to vote later today, but after seeing such blatant bigotry in this ad, I will be voting yes. Thanks for making this choice easier for me.

Jose

marriage is no longer a religious institution owned by the churches. it is civil. when the mormons and catholics start taking on drive through weddings and elvis impersonators as officiants and weddings in made up TV languages as being legitimate, then I will give them some say in how marriage is being conducted. but that ain't gonna happen. religious marriage is a debased institution and has primarily a legal function any more.

i don't see why someone should have to go through 10 steps to get the same legal rights they get with one "i do" and a filled out wedding license.

and churches will not be forced to marry gays, and men will not be forced to marry men, nor any of the other crud that is being slung around. i don't blame the gays for getting a little snippy - they have been slimed repeatedly by this propositions backers

Duwayne Anderson

“Hate” is an emotion that can drive a person to do things that hurt another. Opponents of prop 8 are not hurting Mormons. They are not trying to stop Mormons from marrying, having their temples, or living their private lives as they wish. They are not attempting to have the government treat them as second-class citizens.

But the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS or Mormon) *is* exhibiting hate because their efforts, if successful, will have long-lasting and detrimental effects on the lives of others. They *are* trying to force their religious POV on others. They *are* intruding into the private lives of others. Worse, they are doing this under legal protection that allows them to spread their hate with tax-exempt status.

These are the same tricks I watched the LDS Church play when they up-ended the Equal Rights Amendment. The LDS Church should be ashamed, and those who support the church need to re-evaluate their membership.

Duwayne Anderson
Author of “Farewell to Eden: Coming to terms with Mormonism and science”

wendallyn

Wow- John S., you really are misinformed. Domestic Partnerships in California do NOT have ALL the same rights as marriages. There are hundreds of laws that treat Domestic Partners differently than married couples. I could not change my name legally as a Domestic Partner like you can when you get married. I could not demand spousal rights when signing up for various services provided in the state of California, the title on my house was treated differently, and inheritance laws are not treated the same.
I was fortunate enough on June 21st of this year to marry my partner of 12 years and be legally granted several new rights. Prop 8 would truly deprive us of the rights that all other married couples take for granted. We tried "separate but equal" in the 50's and found that it really wasn't equal at all.

wendallyn

Big Wave Dave,

I'm so disappointed to hear that you are voting Yes on 8! I am a Christian woman, married to another Christian woman, and we have adopted 2 children who otherwise would be stuck in the foster care system. We listen to your radio station all the time, and our girls love listening to your afternoon program.
Please don't take away our rights to be recognized as a true family. Our girls ask us all the time why "straight" people care so much if we are married and it is hard fo find an answer for them. Even our children know that our being married does not affect them, except to give them the chance to feel proud of their family.

JBBW

Just face it. Those of you that are supporting this ban are doing it out of hate. You are just using your religion as a reason to hate. Deep down if your religion preached tolerance you wouldn't have a reason to hate and couldn't vote for it.

Something for the so-called "Christian" to think about.

goliathon8

The Yes on 8 ads concerned with teaching young children that any two people can be married before the children have figured out their sexual identiy are based on what actually happened in Mass.

Yes on 8 is only trying to restore the law and protect marriage.

The Mormon Church did not force any member to do anything. People responded to the concernfor familits

Of course it doesnt matter what I say.... you all non-members know better.

PS The Catholics, and many other churches support yes on proposition 8. But it is probably true that the Mormons are more organized.

Ken

The ad is ridiculous. Mormons aren't using the force of law to stop anyone from living together or sharing a life together or having ceremonies or exchanging rings.

State-licensed marriage is a public matter. The public gets to set some of the terms.

It would make more sense to show gay activists and a judge pushing a "Yes on 22" voter out of her voting booth. Voting is a long-established right, unlike getting a state-issued license (and that goes for ANY marriages).

John Sebastian

I thought we engaged in the Campaign against Hate? I can't believe this! I don't know if I'm alone in this, but I think it's wrong to attack people not only for their sexual preferences, but also for their religion. This is Hate Crime! I just hope that none of those poor boys out serving their Church will be attacked on account of this.

Let's get a grip. I know that we're all engaged in a war for rights here, but I think that we need to draw the line somewhere.

I am ashamed of this video.

Steve Young

Thanks for sharing this. I'm now voting yes on 8.

Jim

I wonder how a commercial showing two gay pedophiles marrying in order to adopt a child would would go over with the gay community. After all, according to the blogger, it is "no big deal".

About the same level of accuracy. Mormons are a small group, easily hurt. I note the Jews and Mulsims and Catholics are left relatively untouched by the opposition. They are easy to pick on. Its nice to know the pro gay community isn't any different from the people they attack. Just slightly less honest.

Buffalo

"I had been undecided, and leaning toward voting no on 8 when I go to vote later today, but after seeing such blatant bigotry in this ad, I will be voting yes. Thanks for making this choice easier for me."

Yes, we all believe you. You're not just a Yes on 8 tool whose making this up to make it seem like you were morally offended. I'm sure you really were undecided.

Jimmy

I'm definitely of the "No on 8" crowd, and while I think it IS right that the Mormans should be made to own up to the damage they're doing to California families, I don't think that inciting further bigotry is a good way to FIGHT bigotry. In a way, right now, I feel that if Prop 8 DOES pass, it will be due in part to this ad. It won't sit well with people who were on the fence. I suppose this is politics though. I can't honestly say that I see anything DISHONEST in what the ad is saying though - the Morman church REALLY IS going out of its way to destroy marriages, something no one can accuse anyone on the No on 8 side of doing. If they get their wish, families that have been legally bound together will be legally torn apart. I see the Courage Campaign as telling the truth, but I also see that they might well help Prop 8 to pass, and that would be terribly sad.

Matthew Areno

It's amazing how people associate love with "approval" and hatred with "disapproval". Simply because I don't agree with what you do doesn't mean I hate you. The fact that you see it that way just shows who the real close-minded person is.

I don't agree with gay marriage, plain and simply. However, I have several gay friends and love them dearly. I don't approve of what they do, but what they do behind closed doors is their business. But once it come out from behind closed door, it's mine, and I don't approve. I consider sexual relations to be special and feel they should be treated as such.

If you call me a hater, it's because you don't agree with how I feel. What then makes you any less hateful than me? Again, love does not equal acceptance or approval. Otherwise, pretty much no one would love anyone but themselves, and often times not even that.

I support the need to provide legal rights, such as power of attorney, to gay couples. Matter of fact, I voted against our states amendment to ban gay marriage because it went too far. However, the attitude of people like this, and those behind this commercial, make me strongly remorse that decision.

Daren Salter

I've been whipsawed by the slick fear-mongering pro-8 ad campaign that have saturated California households over these last weeks. The ads are factually erroneous and ethically disgusting, and skew the issue to make it seem as though the taking away of personal freedoms is a 'do the right thing' call to action. I can only hope that voters are wise enough to resist the fear-mongering and distortion. The 'missionaries' ad is admittedly heavy-handed, but accurate in showing Prop 8 for what it is: The Right to Hate.

PLEASE SAY NO TO HATE— and vote NO on 8!

Fresno

Lifelong Republican and McCain voter AGAINST Prop 8. Not all old, white, heterosexual guys are haters, nor are they all homophobes. As one of the above with 5 kids, I have already voted against this dreadful initiative. BTW, I am not Morman, but have VERY good friends who are, and they do not all support the initiative either.

concernedincalifornia

How can anyone on either side stomach this ad? If there is anyone in this discussion that is still undecided on prop 8 (not likely), does this not make it completely obvious on which side the hate really resides?

Please vote Yes on 8

Jimmy

Jim -
The Jews, Muslims and Catholics were probably "left relatively untouched" because it was more obvious that they were like most groups - split, and not appearing to be a unified force against the gay people. The mormans have been showing with great force and pride that they raised (half? more? less?) a great deal of the money used to attack the gay families in the Yes on 8 campaign. That amount of dedication (and MONEY) does not show the mormans to be a "small group, easily hurt" like you suggest - but a group with lots of money, and the will to use it for no other purpose than to cause harm to families who don't meet their approval.

paddyoski

Bigotry? I think what's hurting this state most is basic cognitive skills. Where in the commercial did the women advocate denying the Mormons the right to practice their religion or don magic underwear?

The answer is simple - government needs to get out of the business of sanctioning marriage and merely administer domestic partnerships for everyone, with full rights for all consenting adults. This isn't a difficult concept. Christian doctrine teaches that God is in the center of a marriage between two people. Nowhere is there a mention of government. The problem isn't gay marriage - it's intrusive government in our personal lives. No On 8, baybee!!

La Linguetta

Whatever your personal views on homosexuality or marriage, this is about the fundamental rights of tax-paying, law-abiding Californians. Civil unions do not provide equal rights -- and, even if they did, how can we forget that separate is NOT equal?

To those who support Proposition 8 because they believe homosexuality is wrong, I would respond that your individual beliefs are less important than the principles of equality. We are all entitled to our opinions; we are not entitled to discriminate against others based on these opinions, absent a compelling interest. There is no compelling interest -- wherein the benefits of discrimination would outweigh the burdens -- in preventing gays from getting married.

Francisco Bruno

No big deal, uh? Well, I would like to see what you would have to say about an ad that depicted a couple of lesbians invading the home of Mormons and tearing apart their religious books, because of their homophobic content...

lee

it's bigotry. straight up bigotry.

to the wendy who talked about how domestic partnerships in california don't have the same rights as married people:

the rights you are discussing are federal rights. and prop 8 has no effect on them, whether or not it passes.

i'm voting yes because i see marriage as society's ultimate expression of equality: it takes one woman and one man.

also, i think children have a right to a mom and dad
http://prop8discussion.wordpress.com/category/another-myth-dispelled/

Jeremy

I can't say I love the tenor of this ad -- I don't -- but there is something to be said for accountability.

The Mormon Church and its members have spearheaded this initiative to make gay and lesbian people second-class citizens in the so-called home of religious tolerance.

Where were the tolerant Mormons speaking to the counterpoint, who publicly recognized that they have benefited from traditions of tolerance and the separation of church and state?

Why is it okay to tear at gay and lesbian families and homes and expect no negative publicity in return? To make ad hominem attacks? To serve as baseless fearmongers?

Why isn't it okay for those of us the Mormon Church and its allies would like to relegate to second-class status to be angry? Why should we be content to be 'less than'?

I would like to think that Proposition 8 will fail, and that its opponents will be magnanimous in victory.

Dalin

You know, there were some mormons voting no on this initiative. Not now....this is so extremely offensive. Mormon missionaries give up 2 years of their lives to help people and they get crap like this. Yep....my vote just switched to a yes on 8.

Lynn

I live in an suburban area that has a larger than avg percentage of mormons. I've continually been surprised and disappointed by the large numbers of people turning out on street corners to take something away from others, something that people seek when they love one another. How can you not call the supporters of Proposition hateful when they want to deny other's this happiness. I'm voting NO and thought the video was great, its NOTHING compared to the blatant LIES the Yes on 8 supporters have been spending lots of $$$ to spread.

Independent

I'm struck that Karin Klein and other find nothing offensive in this ad. I taught a course in Human Sexuality at a university in Florida for a number of years and I was struck by the intolerance some of the writers of the school's Republican newspaper had for the gay students that came to my class to share their experiences. They could not argue the issues and so resorted to personal attacks. This advertisement avoids presenting a case by resorting to the voter's attitudes towards Mormons rather than towards the merits of Proposition 8. In other words, the producers of this ad hope you will rely on feelings of bigotry rather than reason when you go to vote. It seems like careful thought and reasoned discussion are never a part of the voting process. My girlfriend's parents both met as children in Auschwitz do to this same kind of bigotry. Nothing ever changes, does it?

Katie P

The add was created by Courage California, which is a group of former Mormons who were kicked out for being gay.

Also, a Yes on 8 campaign spokesman compared LGBT rights workers as Nazis ..

Zdeb

This add was not run by the No on 8 campaign, but by a separate group. Don't punish gays for this add. Vote No on 8.

Tracy Hall Jr

This absurd video could be believably rewritten with the Castro District thought police descending on a religious household to confiscate their scriptures as "hate speech."

The redefinition of the word "marriage," by judicial fiat, forces most religions to rewrite all their scriptures and teachings to change "marriage" to "marriage between a man and a woman."

And after they complete this enormous task, they will be still open to official prosecution for "hate speech," or perhaps for "contempt of court" in ignoring the decreed definition of "marriage."

There has never been a more sinister and arrogant attack on religious freedom in the history of our republic.

Tracy Hall Jr
hthalljr'gmail'com

Darkrose

I don't know why people are so outraged over this ad, because it shows exactly what's happening. If Prop 8 passes, then tomorrow, I might as well have someone come into my house and rip up the marriage certificate my wife and I got two months ago.

I would never presume to tell someone I didn't know who they were allowed to marry. I'm not sure why it's supposed to be okay for someone else to stick their noses into my life and tell me who it's okay for me to love and to marry. If you don't support gay marriage, then the answer is simple: don't get married to someone of the same gender.

Shawn

This ad is kind of silly, but I find it really hard to believe that anyone religious would find it inherently offensive. It's actually a pretty accurate depiction of what's going on: The LDS and other religious sects are sending millions of dollars into the state to TAKE RIGHTS AWAY FROM PEOPLE. No matter how you cut it, or what your opinion is on gay marriage, that's what's going on.

You can argue all day about why you think gays shouldn't be allowed to marry, but you can't deny the audaciousness of sending shock troops into a state to fight your proxy battle. And anyone that's pro-8 who claims the moral high ground should seriously consider the perversely immoral, deceptive tactics that your campaign is using to win. To cry "bigotry" at a video this benign, this late in the game, really says something about the desperation of the Yes on 8 campaign and the proposition's supporters.

Bottom line: mind your own business. Ours is a nation of law, not of religion, and the legal construct of matrimony exists, by definition, separate from any religious institution. (Remember that the marriages of Hindus, atheists, pagans, and other non-Christian denominations are recognized by the state.) This is a civil rights issue, and if you're for prop 8, you're on the wrong side of the battle. Don't fall for the same bigotry that many Christians did 50 years ago, when Jerry Falwell railed against "miscegenation" and desegregation.

Vote no on 8 if you live in California, and if you don't, keep your grubby, bigoted hands off our Constitution.

Skt

Save marriage and let's ban divorce.

Karin Klein

To Francisco Bruno,

Well, Francisco, if lesbians were trying to stop people of any religion, Mormon or otherwise, from getting married I would of course be outraged and would say that the people from those religions have the right to fight like crazy and to post ads with skits symbolizing what's happening to them.

AW

As if these young missionaries aren't treated badly enough already?

Jimmy

Katie P -
If this is as you say - made by a group of ex-Mormans who were kicked out because they were gay - then I VERY much support the ad after all... They have every right to complain if their own people would do this to them.
I DO think it would have been smart had they added a "credits" section explaining who they were. It's kind of hard to say it's just the "gay community attacking mormans" if these are former mormans who are victims of current ones...

Katherine McNamara

I find it amusing that the Mormon church is so against the separation of church and state... considering they faced persecution by "the law" in the state of IL at their founding (I.e. "hunting season on mormons" being legal).

Seriously, for the religious people who keep saying they want the law to reflect their faith or beliefs (protectmarriage.com)... You're living in the wrong country since the basis of the federal constitution of the United States of America is specific about two things: 1) Equality and 2) Separation of church and state (Please read it sometime). Why would we change either of these principles that our country was founded on? Even on a state level, why should we blur the lines between the separation of church and state or equality? If you're going to vote, look at it objectively... Base it off what the law should be without religion being taken in mind.

Buddy

Katie P is either misinformed, a liar or both. The ad was created by Courage Campaign which is not founded by gay ex-mormons. The nazi comment is also a complete fabrication.

Jeremy

I happen to be married to a Mormon girl. Her brother is gay and grew up LDS. I'm here to tell you that this issue is tearing their family apart.

The Mormon Church should be ashamed at their efforts in this campaign. Prop 8 does nothing constructive. It's only purpose is to take rights away from Californians. After the millions spent of Church tithing to attack gay rights they deserve some heat.

“They are preserving the sanctity of marriage, so that two gay men who've been together for twenty-five years can't get married, but a guy can still get drunk in Vegas and marry a hooker at the Elvis chapel! The sanctity of marriage is saved!”

- Lea DeLaria

Jimmy

Looks like the Mormons won after all. I am PERSONALLY taking a vow right now to never patronize a business that is run by Mormans. They obviously have enough money to destroy other families in California, they sure as hell don't need mine.
California sure has something to be proud of today. We've just shown the world that we have right to talk to anyone about bigotry - we're the kings right here. And I think I might well have just developed my own first REAL prejudice against another group. They've earned it, though.

Justine Barron

Why should the liberals be polite and politically correct when we are being abused? This is comedy, but it's also truth. My friends and I made an improvised mockumentary short, with the same idea: mormon's warped idea of love: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1mHlxySswfM

OBSOLETE

I didn't like the ad, but I am not particularly surprised. Mormons are easy to pick, and therefore easy to portray them in a negative light. Fact is that most of the states that voted on similar measures today voted for marriage in the traditional sense.

And to all the folks that are talking about the other side being filled with "hate" - get a life. Both sides are biased. Gay wants the other side to be tolerant, yet they aren't willing to admit that they are in the minority. The religious community won't say it like they believe it - that it is a sin.


Bottom line - 4 judges over turned the will of the people. That is tyranny in itself. Let the people decide. I have faith in the majority still.

Jimmy

Some possible titles for articles today:
"Mormans Destroy 16,000 marriages in California"
"H8 Wins the Day! Californians Proud!"
"Civil Rights Take Historic Step Backwards In California"
...
I have more ideas but they might sound a little bitter.

Jimmy

I forgot the best one:
"Californians Vote to Treat Animals Better Than Homosexuals"

CP

Why are the Mormons upset by this ad? It's exactly what they did. I've got news for you all: telling the world you don't hate gay people doesn't make it true. You do. You chose to single out an entire population of people who have nothing to do with you and spent millions of dollars to strip them of basic rights.

You are evil, plain and simple. You will get your just reward in the next life - you can bet on it.

bravo

Its good to know that bigotry is alive and well today and also socially acceptable...

Rex Hump

I guess it was easier to attack Mormons then any other church.... In real life they would've shut the door on them... the chances of a missionary getting inside 1000 to 1.

 
1 2 | »

Connect

Advertisement

In Case You Missed It...

Video


Categories


Recent Posts
Reading Supreme Court tea leaves on 'Obamacare' |  March 27, 2012, 5:47 pm »
Candidates go PG-13 on the press |  March 27, 2012, 5:45 am »
Santorum's faulty premise on healthcare reform |  March 26, 2012, 5:20 pm »

Archives
 


About the Bloggers
The Opinion L.A. blog is the work of Los Angeles Times Editorial Board membersNicholas Goldberg, Robert Greene, Carla Hall, Jon Healey, Sandra Hernandez, Karin Klein, Michael McGough, Jim Newton and Dan Turner. Columnists Patt Morrison and Doyle McManus also write for the blog, as do Letters editor Paul Thornton, copy chief Paul Whitefield and senior web producer Alexandra Le Tellier.



In Case You Missed It...