Registry of DUI offenders?
An Arizona county attorney has a new idea way of combating drunk driving, and it seems almost inspired by Megan's Law. From The New York Times:
A conviction for driving under the influence of alcohol is something many people try to conceal, even from their families. But now the bleary-eyed, disheveled and generally miserable visages of convicted drunken drivers here, captured in their mug shots, are available to the entire world via a Web site.
The hall of shame is even worse for drunken drivers convicted of a felony. A select few will find their faces plastered on billboards around Phoenix with the banner headline: Drive drunk, see your mug shot here. [...]
The purposes of the billboards and the Web site, Mr. Thomas has said, are to inform the public about drunken-driving laws, and to serve as a deterrent.
There's a key difference here, though. Megan's Law isn't (just) about deterrence by public shame. It's meant as a tool to protect children and others against sex offenders. But publishing a database of unflattering photos doesn't really help potential victims of drunk driving — unless you're a passenger in that driver's car. Then again, drunk drivers do tend to be repeat offenders, so perhaps these shame tactics will have some deterrent effect in the long run.
Embarrassment is one thing — but if this catches on outside Arizona, it could turn out to be a danger to those listed. That's what just happened with Megan's law, according to today's L.A. Times:
Convicted rapist Michael A. Dodele had been free just 35 days when sheriff's deputies found him dead last month in his aging, tan mobile home, his chest and left side punctured with stab wounds. [...]
Prosecutors said they have investigated the possibility that the slaying of Dodele, 67, stemmed from his having been listed on the state's Megan's Law database of sex offenders. If so, his death may be the first in the state to result from such a listing, experts said.






What if an individual had a substance abuse or other medical problem, which might be deemed a disability, and contributed to their drinking and driving? Would it be within the law in this legislation to identify them in public if the disability were obvious?
I mean, where do you stop in these type of campaigns. Why not also do it to employers who hire illegal immigrants, or those who extort money from little old ladies? I see all kinds of kinks in the above described approach.
Posted by: Stephen | December 10, 2007 at 05:19 PM
If I have a neighbor who is always shirking his responsibility by driving under the influence, then I want to know because he could be offering a ride to my children or grandchildren.
Just like wanting to know about sex offenders because of the damage they can to to my family, I don't want a disrespectful drive to do the same.
Posted by: JW Morrison | September 04, 2008 at 08:55 PM
I live in Maricopa County where this list is posted. DUI arrests and convictions are, like any other crime, "public records", which means that anyone can go check on an individual to see if they have a DUI or any other conviction. This principle of arrests and convictions being public records dates back to English Law, and even predates our Constitution. Any individual has the right to go in and examine criminal public records and receive copies of these records and has the right to republish them on the internet if he so chooses.
Posted by: F. Wilson | September 05, 2008 at 08:46 AM
The University of Southern California, and the University of Pennsylvania .This principle of arrests and convictions being public records dates back to English Law, and even predates our Constitution. Any individual has the right to go in and examine criminal public records and receive copies of these records and has the right to republish them on the internet.
=========================
brian
DUI
Posted by: Brian2008 | November 14, 2008 at 01:03 AM
Well, that idea brings back memories of the scared straight videos from the 1980's. It could work to curb drunk driving, but don't think it will really have much of an effect. People are pretty ammune to ths type of advertising and live in the now and don't really think about what might happen in the future.
Posted by: Arizona DUI Laws | September 22, 2010 at 03:34 PM