Creature comforts, Sacramento style
A high five -- or a low, furry-pawed four -- for Arnold Schwarzenegger and Sheila James Kuehl, two names you don't often read together in the same context.
The California Republican governor just signed a bill by the Democratic state senator that allows criminal and family courts to include family pets in domestic violence protective orders.
People laughed at that renowned "National Lampoon" cover, "If You Don't Buy This Magazine, We'll Kill This Dog."
But in the real world it's not remotely funny. The FBI links violence against animals as a predictor of violence against humans. Kuehl cited a 1997 survey of 50 of the nation's largest domestic violence shelters that concluded that 85% of women and 63% of children coming into the shelters mentioned pet abuse, and far more than half of the women looking for shelter from abusive partners say their family pets were threatened, hurt or killed. And children who witness or suffer abuse are themselves likelier to hurt a pet in turn.
"This legislation will prevent abusers from harming or threatening to harm animals in order to exert power and control over their human victims," said Kuehl.
Even if you don't care much about animals, you can appreciate that some domestic abuse victims stay in the house -- and put themselves and maybe their children at greater risk -- because they have no place to take the pet, or they refuse to leave a defenseless creature behind to the "mercy" of the abuser, or both.
The Kuehl bill addresses part of the problem, but not all of it.
Police, district attorneys and animal welfare groups supported the bill, but the Oroville, California Mercury-Register reported that a local domestic violence shelter took no stand on the bill because of concerns that shelters can't house the imperiled pets.
It's a valid point. It's all well and good to extend paper protection to pets, and long overdue, but unless there's a place to shelter them, as there is for the families who love them and fear for them, the protection is just paper. Only other pieces of paper -- the legislation and the money to back it up -- can give this law ... well, there's no other way to say it -- real teeth.


Thank you, Pat, for backing up the information with a call to further action. As one of a team of University of San Diego graduate students who drafted the early iteration and then advocated for this bill (thank you Senator Kuehl for taking it on!), we recognized in framing this issue -- the connection between domestic violence toward humans and animals -- that baby steps can lead to enormous strides. Let's keep the dialog and the protection moving forward!
Posted by: Gretchen Pelletier | September 25, 2007 at 09:35 AM
Thank you for calling attention to this brand new bill. Every layer of power that can be exposed and stripped from the abuser can help give victims a better chance of escaping their situation. Yes, this is a first step. Without it, the next one cannot happen, so please let us all do whatever is in our power to continue this process. Nice job.
Posted by: Patti Londre | September 25, 2007 at 10:07 AM
since 1995 spcala has been running the Animal Safety Net Program which is designed to temporarily house pets of victims of domestic violence so that they do not have to leave the pets behind. the victim is then free to go into a shelter and deal with starting a new life. they can pick up their pet when they are ready to leave the shelter. although some los angeles judges have included the pet on protective orders - it was not a statewide practice. spcala was pushing for legislation that would rectify this and commends senator kuehl for her efforts in this area. our ASN info line is 323 733 0219 and the emergency hotline is 888 527 7722. this program is funded by donations and grants.
Posted by: madeline bernstein | September 25, 2007 at 11:18 AM
With people and now the courts acknowledging the link between animal abuse and domestic violence, we are taking the appropriate steps to protect all family members. Although at the present time some shelters do not have programs to temporarily house or foster pets from abusive situations, in time they will. This is just the first step. For examples of how good programs are run, shelters need look no further than SPCALA in Los Angeles or Rancho Coastal Humane Society in San Diego County.
Posted by: jill buckley | September 25, 2007 at 11:37 AM
any kind of violence is domestic, wife, child, husband, and above all animals
it should all be procacuted
Posted by: carol | October 02, 2007 at 07:19 PM