Opinion L.A.

The best in Southern California opinion journalism,
Monday through Friday

« Previous Post | Opinion L.A. Home | Next Post »

You can take the judge out of the Bronx...

February 22, 2007 |  2:00 pm

The case for television coverage of the Supreme Court is an easy one because only lawyers and justices are affected, not witnesses. It's trickier to make the case for cameras in trial courts, but televised trials do have one advantage: They showcase the diversity of what H.L. Mencken called the American language.

Case in point: The Florida judge who presided -- and so much more -- at Thursday's hearing over the disposition of Anna Nicole Smith's remains. Forget about Broward Circuit Judge Larry Seidlin's emotionalism; how about that Noo Yawk accent? He sounded so much like Mike Myers' female alter ego that I expected him to ask the parties to discuss the case "amongt yourselves."

Televised trials -- which were the staple of Court TV before Nancy Grace -- offer a many-leveled corrective to the way the judicial system is portrayed in movie and TV drama.  In real trials, events do not move swiftly to a denouement and lawyers often stumble,  repeat themselves and  lose their train of thought.

Perhaps the biggest distortion in Hollywood's depiction of trials is the diction of the presiding judges. Casting directors looking for a judicial presence usually choose deep-voiced actors with an impeccable mid-Atlantic accent. But  real judges sound like other people from the communities where the judges live -- or, as in Judge Seidlin's case, where they grew up

One TV series that gives us vernacular verisimilitude is "Law and Order," on which the judges  -- including one played by the writer Fran Lebowitz  -- often sound like honest-to-Gawd New Yorkers. If Fran is busy next season, Dick Wolf should call Judge Seidlin.


Post a comment
If you are under 13 years of age you may read this message board, but you may not participate.
Here are the full legal terms you agree to by using this comment form.

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until they've been approved.

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In





Comments
1.

I grew up only 29 miles from New York City.
I was surrounded by law firms.
There they were.
Down the street, up the street, around the corner, and so on.
Now I know why lawyers with "NY" accents are everywhere from Florida to TV land.
There is no more room for them back home.
But I do like the "real" trials.
They give a better understanding of the slow legal process.
Maybe TV should show more lawyers per scene.
That would make it more real.

George Vreeland Hill



Advertisement

About the Bloggers
Opinion L.A. is the work of the Los Angeles Times editorial board.



Recent Posts
Thanksgiving thoughts |  November 27, 2009, 8:58 am »
Chapter and verse on a litmus test |  November 24, 2009, 6:44 pm »
Dream (or nightmare) team |  November 24, 2009, 11:16 am »
Making a list and checking it seven times |  November 24, 2009, 11:13 am »

Archives