More on campus attitudes
Jonathan Lamy, a spokesman for the RIAA, responded to my previous post with a chart showing a sharp decline in the number of infringement notices sent to college campuses that had been piracy hotbeds in 2006-07. Contrary to the highly unscientific sample I cited, these numbers suggest that the RIAA's enforcement efforts have made an impact on campus. Of course, students may have simply gotten better at concealing their file-sharing from The Man, found an alternative source of free music to replace Bit Torrent and Limewire, or put off their downloading until after Spring Break. But here's Jonathan's explanation of the data, followed by the chart (which you can download here) after the jump:
This is a ranking of schools receiving the most DMCA notices a year ago. We think the notices are a pretty good indicator of the extent of piracy on a campus: completely objective -- we are simply crawling the Internet and whatever we find, a notice is sent to the school. Because of these notices, because of the pre-lawsuit letters, because of the focus of Congress on these issues, many schools taken rigorous steps to discourage students from visiting illegal sites. Look at the notice reduction column during the past year. That means that many fewer incidences of piracy found on those campus networks, which used to have the most prolific incidences of piracy. That, I think, is pretty compelling and a different way of looking at the impact of our collective efforts.
| 2006-07 Top 20 | DMCA notices 06-07 | DMCA notices 07-08 | Change | Current rank |
| University of South Carolina | 914 | 45 | -869 | 166 |
| University of Massachusetts at Amherst | 765 | 713 | -52 | 2 |
| Michigan State University | 718 | 82 | -636 | 118 |
| Purdue University | 679 | 458 | -221 | 14 |
| University of Nebraska-Lincoln | 653 | 450 | -203 | 16 |
| University of Tennesee-Knoxville | 651 | 372 | -279 | 25 |
| Howard University | 569 | 10 | -559 | 314 |
| Ohio University | 526 | 67 | -459 | 141 |
| University of Maine | 440 | 461 | 21 | 12 |
| University of Wisconsin-Madison | 407 | 383 | -24 | 23 |
| North Carolina State University | 387 | 593 | 206 | 6 |
| University of Wisconsin - Eau Claire | 382 | 134 | -248 | 83 |
| Syracuse University | 373 | 73 | -300 | 134 |
| Kent State University | 363 | 151 | -212 | 70 |
| Boston University | 349 | 425 | 76 | 17 |
| Northern Michigan University | 344 | 30 | -314 | 198 |
| University of South Florida | 388 | 117 | -271 | 95 |
| University of Wisconsin-Whitewater | 315 | 0 | -315 | n/a |
| Indiana University | 284 | 101 | -183 | 106 |
Source: RIAA

Hypothetically, let's say that instead of students enjoying an epiphany of respect for copyright, that they were instead completely incorrigible. The reduction in DMCA notices could still be explained.
Perhaps the RIAA has decided to give up on some universities to focus a smaller budget on others? One assumes it is actually in control of the DMCA notices it issues...
Alternatively, some universities may have become saturated with the works that students desire and thus there are ever fewer forays off the campus network via easily traceable facilities such as BitTorrent.
To conclude that students can be subdued into compliance by pleasant DMCA notices that threaten their educational prospects seems like a hopeful interpretation of RIAA deciding to issue fewer DMCA notices.
However, let's say that such hopes are fulfilled. This then demonstrates that no further technical or legal solution is needed to combat copyright infringement, RIAA has all the ability it needs to continue issuing DMCA notices wherever necessary to soon instill in all Internet users a proper respect for copyright.
Posted by: Crosbie Fitch | February 22, 2008 at 02:10 AM
The infringement that they can track has gone down. College kids are inventive in the way they use technology. They know that they can be tracked downloading in traditional ways, and know they've gone underground by using encryption or other technologies the RIAA is not privy to.
Where did Google come from? Oh right. A dorm room.
-Adam
Have You Heard?
haveyouheard.net
Posted by: Adam | February 22, 2008 at 10:16 AM